The Most Dangerous Mistake You Can Make When Hiring
Eben Pagan reveals the most dangerous mistake in hiring: making decisions based on liking someone rather than their ability to perform. He shares how to identify and treat star employees while avoiding the common pitfall of emotional estimation.
Teachings 5
Emotional estimation is most dangerous when hiring - saying 'I really like this person' is a red flag that indicates poor hiring judgment
Brad Smart, author of Top Grading, reports 75% of all hires are mis-hires across business universally. Only 1 in 4 hires are successful.
The quality of your team determines business importance - Microsoft would become unimportant without their top 20 people out of 20,000 employees
Bill Gates quote: 'Take our 20 best people away and I will tell you that Microsoft would become an unimportant company' - 20 people out of 20,000 total employees.
When star employees make costly mistakes, focus on learning rather than punishment to maintain team loyalty and performance
Eben's team regularly makes mistakes costing $50,000-$100,000. His response: call them, ask 'what did you learn?' and frame it as a cheap lesson compared to when the business is 5x larger and it would cost $500,000.
Punitive responses to mistakes create employee resentment and deliberate sabotage over time
Eben explains the progression: initial response 'yeah you're right I am an idiot' evolves into 'I don't really care if this gets screwed up and costs the company $50,000 because you're a bastard and you deserve it.' He's witnessed this pattern 'many many times.'
Surround yourself with people better than you to accelerate growth and learning
Confucius quote: 'Never contract a friendship with a man that is not better than thyself.' Eben calls his team 'my Mastermind' and 'my influence group.'
Perspectives 1
The 'employees suck' attitude creates confirmation bias where you only see validation of employee failures
Eben observes 99 out of 100 entrepreneurs have this attitude. He contrasts this with his own experience where the first thing he says about loving his business is 'it's the team' and 'these amazing people I get to learn from.'
Quotable Moments 5
“take our 20 best people away and I will tell you that Microsoft would become an unimportant company”
— Bill Gates“never contract a friendship with a man that is not better than thyself”
— Confucius“I really like them liking a person can be one of the most dangerous things when it comes to hiring people”
— Eben Pagan“it was cheap lesson I'm glad you learned it now rather than when we're at five times our size and it would have been a $500,000 lesson”
— Eben Pagan“first thing I say is it's the team it's these amazing people that I get to learn from all the time day after day these are my Mastermind this is my influence group”
— Eben Pagan
How to Avoid Dangerous Hiring Mistakes
A framework for making better hiring decisions by avoiding emotional estimation and focusing on performance indicators
- 1
Recognize the red flag
When you find yourself saying 'I really like this person' during an interview, stop and evaluate whether you're assessing their ability to do the job or just their likability
- 2
Separate performance from personality
Ask specific questions about their ability to perform the role rather than focusing on personal chemistry or how much you enjoy talking with them
- 3
Use structured evaluation
Implement systematic hiring processes that evaluate competency rather than relying on gut feelings or emotional responses
- 4
Plan your mistake response
Before hiring, decide how you'll handle expensive mistakes - focus on learning rather than punishment to maintain star employee loyalty
Questions Answered
What percentage of hires are unsuccessful according to hiring experts?
“Brad smart the author of top grading who he's going to do a tel class uh for the group as part of this altitude program he says that something like 75% of all hires are Mish hires 75% it's kind of universally across the board in business so only one and four was a good one”
— Eben Pagan▶ 1:33
75% of all hires are mis-hires according to Brad Smart, author of Top Grading. This means only 1 in 4 hires are actually successful.
What is the most dangerous mistake when hiring employees?
“I really like this person that's it I really like them liking a person can be one of the most dangerous things when it comes to hiring people”
— Eben Pagan▶ 1:33
The most dangerous hiring mistake is emotional estimation - making decisions based on liking someone rather than their ability to perform the job.
How should you respond when star employees make expensive mistakes?
“what I do is I call the person up typically and I say hey how you doing and usually if it's a star they're already bummed out right they're already beating themselves up and I say what did you learn what what's the lesson you got from it you know we all have we all have rough days it's okay don't worry about it what what what's the lesson you got because guess what it was cheap lesson I'm glad you learned it now rather than when we're at five times our size and it would have been a $500,000 lesson”
— Eben Pagan▶ 5:08
Focus on learning rather than punishment. Ask 'what did you learn?' and frame it as a cheap lesson compared to future growth.
Why do most entrepreneurs struggle with team management?
“if you think employees suck and we have a mechanism in our mind that only sees validation what are you going to do when you hire people you're only going to look at the places where they suck and you're only going to see the validation for that stuff”
— Eben Pagan▶ 4:28
Most entrepreneurs have an 'employees suck' attitude that creates confirmation bias, causing them to only see validation of employee failures.
How important are top performers to company success?
“take our 20 best people away and I will tell you that Microsoft would become an unimportant company Bill Gates”
— Eben Pagan
Top performers are critical - Bill Gates said Microsoft would become unimportant without their top 20 people out of 20,000 employees.
Summary
The Critical Importance of Star Performers
Eben opens with Bill Gates' powerful insight that Microsoft's top 20 people out of 20,000 employees determine whether the company remains important. This sets the stage for understanding why hiring decisions are so crucial to business success.
The Dangerous Trap of Emotional Estimation
The core problem in hiring is emotional estimation - making decisions based on liking someone rather than their competency. Even trained HR professionals fall into this trap, contributing to the 75% mis-hire rate across all businesses.
The 'Employees Suck' Attitude Problem
Most entrepreneurs develop a negative view of employees that creates confirmation bias, causing them to only see failures rather than recognizing team members as business creators. This mindset becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Managing Star Employees Through Mistakes
When star employees make expensive mistakes, the response determines long-term loyalty and performance. Focusing on learning rather than punishment maintains trust and prevents the downward spiral into deliberate sabotage that punitive management creates.
Counterpoint
Claim: “Hire people you really like and have good chemistry with”
Reframe: Liking someone during an interview should trigger a red flag - emotional estimation leads to poor hiring decisions
75% of all hires are mis-hires according to Brad Smart. A trained HR expert told Eben 'I really like them' when asked about a candidate's job performance potential.
Claim: “Employees generally suck and will disappoint you”
Reframe: Great team members are what create your business success and should be your primary source of joy
99 out of 100 entrepreneurs have the 'employees suck' attitude, but Eben says the first thing he loves about his business is 'the team' and 'these amazing people I get to learn from all the time.'
Claim: “When employees make costly mistakes, you need to reprimand them to prevent future errors”
Reframe: Treat expensive mistakes as cheap learning opportunities and support star employees through their recovery
Eben's team makes $50,000-$100,000 mistakes regularly. His response: 'what did you learn?' and 'it was a cheap lesson - I'm glad you learned it now rather than when we're 5x our size and it would be a $500,000 lesson.'
Key Points 6
Emotional estimation is most dangerous when hiring - saying 'I really like this person' is a red flag that indicates poor hiring judgment
▶ 1:33The quality of your team determines business importance - Microsoft would become unimportant without their top 20 people out of 20,000 employees
When star employees make costly mistakes, focus on learning rather than punishment to maintain team loyalty and performance
▶ 5:08The 'employees suck' attitude creates confirmation bias where you only see validation of employee failures
▶ 3:05Punitive responses to mistakes create employee resentment and deliberate sabotage over time
▶ 5:40Surround yourself with people better than you to accelerate growth and learning
▶ 0:31Related Content
Power People
Why the team members you hire will either make or break your business—and the counterintuitive hiring strategy that built Eben's multi-million dollar company.
Tips For Building A Team
The shocking truth: most people you hire will cost your business 20 times their annual salary when they fail.
Learning Learn
Discover why traditional learning fails entrepreneurs and how to transform your brain into a self-building computer that adapts to any situation.
Creating Conditions Success
Why successful entrepreneurs stop thinking about money as value and use a simple 'T-Time/R-Time' system to dramatically increase their productivity and profits.
Managing Your People Your Products
Learn the exact management framework Eben Pagan uses to build high-performing virtual teams that drive millions in revenue.
Interview With Eben Pagan (David DeAngelo) From Double Your ...
How a self-made entrepreneur built a $25 million business from a single ebook and discovered the psychological levels that determine business success.
Topics
Coaching Strategies
Business Frameworks
Common Mistakes