Incentive Systems
MisconceptionIncentive systems are one of the most dangerous ideas ever to hit business because they destroy intrinsic motivation and create dependency. They transform motivated performers into system-gamers who focus on working the incentive structure rather than achieving genuine results.
About Incentive Systems
Incentive systems are one of the most dangerous ideas ever to hit business because they destroy intrinsic motivation and create dependency. They transform motivated performers into system-gamers who focus on working the incentive structure rather than achieving genuine results.
Research shows external rewards can kill intrinsic motivation, as demonstrated in experiments where children lost interest in activities they previously enjoyed after being incentivized. Real-world examples include salespeople who become smooth talkers focused on gaming commission structures rather than truly serving clients.
“incentives in my personal opinion are one of the most dangerous ideas ever to hit business”
— Eben Paganon Warning about the risks of implementing incentive systems
Perspective
“Incentives motivate people to perform better and achieve desired outcomes”
Incentives destroy intrinsic motivation and create system-gaming behavior that undermines genuine performance
Evidence 7
Incentives are one of the most dangerous ideas ever to hit business and should be used with extreme caution
Eben Pagan states he has never heard of a system to quickly give people intrinsic motivation, but has heard of experimen
From: Offering Incentives As Motivation Could Backfire On YouExternal rewards can destroy intrinsic motivation, making people lose interest in activities they previously enjoyed
Research experiment with children and coloring books: kids given gold stars for coloring lost interest when rewards were
From: Offering Incentives As Motivation Could Backfire On Youat 2:38Once you introduce incentives, you cannot test whether people would have performed without them, creating a permanent dependency
Eben explains that changing commission processes on salespeople 'doesn't usually go over very well' and once someone get
From: Offering Incentives As Motivation Could Backfire On Youat 4:44Incentives create 'game the system' behavior where people focus on working the system rather than achieving genuine results
Story from Wheeler's 'Understanding Variation' about a shift supervisor who moved finished products back onto the convey
From: Offering Incentives As Motivation Could Backfire On Youat 5:48People motivated by incentives are often smooth talkers who over-promise and under-deliver to meet their targets
Eben describes how incentivized salespeople talk clients into things by 'promising a little more than you can really del
From: Offering Incentives As Motivation Could Backfire On Youat 7:25Advertising can 'unsell' customers just like incentives can demotivate employees
David Ogilvy in 'Ogilvy on Advertising' talks about how advertising can unsell customers - you can spend money on ads th
From: Offering Incentives As Motivation Could Backfire On Youat 1:02Share wealth and proceeds fairly with your team while avoiding performance-based incentive traps
Eben advocates to 'share the wealth of course share the proceeds that come so that everyone looks around and says yep th
From: Offering Incentives As Motivation Could Backfire On Youat 8:28Evidence
Research shows external rewards can kill intrinsic motivation, as demonstrated in experiments where children lost interest in activities they previously enjoyed after being incentivized. Real-world examples include salespeople who become smooth talkers focused on gaming commission structures rather than truly serving clients.
Quotes
“incentives in my personal opinion are one of the most dangerous ideas ever to hit business”
— Eben Pagan
“the first type of behavior that it creates is how do I work the system how do I game the system to get what I want to get out of it”
— Eben Pagan
“be very careful with incentives they do not work out logically the way you think they are going to”
— Eben Pagan
Source Content 1
Offering Incentives As Motivation Could Backfire On You