Teaching2014-11-03

Mindset Shift Expert Marketer

Mindset Shift Expert Marketer

Eben Pagan reveals the critical mindset shift from being an expert to becoming a marketer in information product businesses. He explains why most experts fail at selling their knowledge and provides the marketer's approach to thinking in needs and niches first.

Mindset Shift Expert Marketer

0:00--:--
Listen:Website

The Foundation: Building Information Product Businesses

Eben opens by explaining that information product businesses require patience and persistence to build all components and connect them together. Success comes when you see the first sales and customers, which provides the inspiration to optimize further.

Expert-itis: The Fatal Flaw of Knowledge Workers

The core problem experts face is believing their knowledge should automatically attract customers. Eben describes how experts view marketing as beneath them and expect people to seek them out, using university professors as a prime example.

The Marketer's Advantage: Putting Customers First

Successful information marketers prioritize marketing skills over expertise, often hiring experts to create content. They understand that customers must be educated to value and only care about 'What's In It For Me.'

Needs and Niches: The Marketer's Secret Weapon

The most successful approach starts with customer needs through direct interviews, expecting most attempts to fail, and systematically testing everything. True validation only comes when customers vote with their money through actual purchases.

Questions This Episode Answers

Why do experts struggle to sell their information products?

Experts feel like I've invested all this time to learn this information, and the world should beat a path to my door. They should show up and try to just force the money into my hand so that I can talk about some of the things that I learned in a casual way.

Eben Pagan2:07

Experts suffer from 'expert-itis' - they believe people should automatically recognize the value of their knowledge and come to them. They view marketing as beneath them and expect customers to seek them out rather than learning how to effectively communicate value.

What's the difference between expert thinking and marketer thinking?

Experts feel that people should know the value of things when they see them. Marketers know that people have to be educated to the value.

Eben Pagan4:24

Experts start with what they know and expect people to recognize its value automatically. Marketers start with customer needs, educate prospects about value, and understand that customers only care about 'What's In It For Me' (WIIFM).

How do successful information marketers approach product creation?

Marketers think in needs and niches. So marketers start with the need of the customer. What most authors and teachers do is they start with what they've got.

Eben Pagan6:23

They think in needs and niches first, starting with customer problems rather than their own expertise. They interview customers to understand their exact words for describing problems, then create products that address those specific needs.

Why do most marketing attempts fail according to successful marketers?

Marketers know that eight or nine out of ten things they try to sell, it's not going to work. That ad's not going to work. That piece isn't going to work. This appeal isn't going to work.

Eben Pagan8:13

Marketers expect most attempts to fail - knowing that 8 or 9 out of 10 ads, appeals, or products won't work. This realistic expectation makes them test systematically and create better marketing because they're not attached to any single approach.

What does WIIFM mean in marketing?

Marketers know that the only channel that other people are tuned to is WIIFM which is what in it for me.

Eben Pagan5:08

WIIFM stands for 'What's In It For Me' - the only channel that customers and prospects are tuned to. People don't care about your brilliant ideas or expertise; they only want to know how it benefits them specifically.

When does a marketing strategy actually work?

It never works until the customer votes with their money. Very important rule. It doesn't work until the customer has voted with their money.

Eben Pagan9:16

A marketing strategy only works when customers vote with their money. Nothing is validated until actual purchases happen - theoretical value or expert opinion doesn't count as proof that something works.

How to Shift from Expert to Marketer Mindset

A framework for transforming from knowledge-focused expert thinking to customer-needs-focused marketer thinking

  1. 1

    Start with customer needs

    Instead of leading with your expertise, begin by identifying what your customers actually want and need

  2. 2

    Interview customers one-on-one

    Conduct direct interviews with 100+ customers over 30 days to understand their biggest fears, problems, and frustrations in their exact words

  3. 3

    Expect most things not to work

    Adopt the realistic expectation that 8-9 out of 10 marketing attempts will fail, which makes you more strategic and less attached

  4. 4

    Test everything systematically

    Create systems for testing different approaches like McDonald's franchise prototypes, rolling out only what proves successful

  5. 5

    Wait for money votes

    Only consider something validated when customers actually purchase, not when they express interest or theoretical approval

All Teachings 12

foundational_insightEmpowering0:30

Information product businesses require building and connecting all components before they start generating results - persistence is needed until you see first sales and website visitors

Eben explains that once all components are connected and you 'fire up the motor' and get first sales, customers, and website visitors, that's when you see it's possible and get inspired to tune it up further

ReframeEmpowering2:07

Experts suffer from 'expert-itis' - believing the world should beat a path to their door and that they shouldn't have to do marketing because they've invested time learning information

Eben describes how experts feel entitled that people should 'force money into my hand so I can talk about things I learned in a casual way' and believe marketing is for 'common people that don't have ethics or morals'

Expert InsightEmpowering3:17

Sales and marketing are considered second-class jobs by experts, like university professors who blame publishing companies when their books don't sell

Eben gives specific example of university professors who write books, expect everyone to buy them, then blame the book publishing company when sales fail, saying 'it was their fault because they didn't market it well'

TeachingEmpowering3:48

Most successful information marketers are marketers first and experts second, with many making millions selling products they're not even experts on

Eben states that successful marketers 'go and get the expert to create the content' because they're such good marketers, and emphasizes 'it's not about the content, it's about the marketing'

ReframeEmpowering4:24

Experts assume people should recognize value automatically, while marketers know customers must be educated to understand value

Eben contrasts how experts think 'when they see it, they should know how valuable this is, and if they don't, they're stupid' versus marketers who 'put it into terms that they can understand'

TeachingEmpowering5:08

Customers only tune into WIIFM (What's In It For Me) - they don't care about your brilliant ideas and will tune out any pretense or arrogance

Eben explains that prospects 'want to learn things that they can relate to from people that they can relate to that are like them' and any pretense makes them 'just tune out'

ReframeEmpowering5:58

If you're trying to talk people into wanting what you're selling or convince people to buy, you've already lost

Eben emphasizes this principle twice in the episode, stating that successful marketers create products that 'sell themselves' rather than requiring persuasion

TeachingEmpowering6:23

Marketers think in needs and niches - starting with customer needs rather than what's in their existing product

Eben contrasts authors who say 'in my book, I teach this and that' with effective marketers who ask 'What does your customer want? What do they need? Because that's all that matters'

TeachingEmpowering7:04

Effective marketers interview customers one-on-one to understand their biggest fears, problems, and frustrations using the customer's exact words

Eben gives specific example: 'I interviewed 100 of my customers over a period of 30 days, one-on-one, and I listened to the words that they said, and here's the biggest fear, problem, frustration, anxiety that they said'

Expert InsightEmpowering8:13

Marketers expect customers NOT to buy and know that 8 or 9 out of 10 marketing attempts won't work

Eben explains that marketers 'know that eight or nine out of ten things they try to sell, it's not going to work' including ads, pieces, and appeals, so they 'turn their brains on and make every single thing count'

TeachingEmpowering8:44

Successful marketers have no attachment to what works or doesn't work - they test everything systematically like McDonald's

Eben uses McDonald's as example, explaining they have 'franchise prototypes set up in different markets where they make tweaks and changes' and 'when they find something that works, they then roll it out'

TeachingEmpowering9:16

Nothing works until the customer votes with their money - customer purchase is the only true validation

Eben emphasizes this as a 'Very important rule' and states that marketers only consider something successful 'if customers vote with their money, then they say it works'

Episode Tone
6 foundational4 intermediate2 advanced

Key Teachings 12

Information product businesses require building and connecting all components before they start generating results - persistence is needed until you see first sales and website visitors

0:30

Experts suffer from 'expert-itis' - believing the world should beat a path to their door and that they shouldn't have to do marketing because they've invested time learning information

2:07

Sales and marketing are considered second-class jobs by experts, like university professors who blame publishing companies when their books don't sell

3:17

Most successful information marketers are marketers first and experts second, with many making millions selling products they're not even experts on

3:48

Experts assume people should recognize value automatically, while marketers know customers must be educated to understand value

4:24

Customers only tune into WIIFM (What's In It For Me) - they don't care about your brilliant ideas and will tune out any pretense or arrogance

5:08

If you're trying to talk people into wanting what you're selling or convince people to buy, you've already lost

5:58

Marketers think in needs and niches - starting with customer needs rather than what's in their existing product

6:23

Effective marketers interview customers one-on-one to understand their biggest fears, problems, and frustrations using the customer's exact words

7:04

Marketers expect customers NOT to buy and know that 8 or 9 out of 10 marketing attempts won't work

8:13

Successful marketers have no attachment to what works or doesn't work - they test everything systematically like McDonald's

8:44

Nothing works until the customer votes with their money - customer purchase is the only true validation

9:16

Scroll for more

Counterpoint 3

Claim:Experts believe that having valuable knowledge means people should automatically want to buy from them

Reframe: Successful information marketers prioritize marketing skills over expertise and focus on customer needs first

Claim:People should recognize the value of expert knowledge when they see it

Reframe: Customers must be educated to understand value and will only engage with messaging that addresses their specific needs

Claim:Marketing and sales are second-class jobs beneath the dignity of true experts

Reframe: Marketing is the highest priority skill that determines success in information product businesses

Quotable Moments

If you're trying to talk people into wanting what you're selling, you've already lost.

Eben Pagan5:58

It's not about the content. It's about the marketing.

Eben Pagan3:48

Marketers think in needs and niches. So marketers start with the need of the customer.

Eben Pagan6:23

It doesn't work until the customer has voted with their money.

Eben Pagan9:16

The only channel that other people are tuned to is WIIFM which is what in it for me.

Eben Pagan5:08

Topics

Coaching Strategies

needs-first thinkingcustomer interviewssystematic testingvalue educationnatural selling

Business Frameworks

WIIFMneeds and nichesinformation product businessMcDonaldization

Common Mistakes

expert-itisassuming automatic value recognitionego-driven communicationpersuasive sellingproduct-first thinking

You Might Be Interested In

You can increase perceived value by 10x to 100x by refining your communication and learning skills to frame everything as having much more value.

Some books sell for $10 while others sell for $1,000 - the difference is in how value is communicated, not the information itself.

Adopt the mindset that you're teaching one person alone, not a group - talk to individuals who are experiencing your content by themselves from their perspective.

When someone says 'hi, all of you out there,' an individual listener thinks 'I'm not all of you out there, I'm an individual' and the connection breaks.

Use the 'give, give, give, get' formula to build customer relationships where the prospect always receives more value than they provide

Eben demonstrates this with a specific website sequence: offer valuable content for opt-in, send newsletters/podcasts/videos as follow-up, then ask for a purchase, then give more value before the next sales request

Connect with prospects on something substantial, particularly shared challenges or problems, as this creates emotional relaxation and trust

Research shows people who listen to the same type of music are more similar than any other demographic factor, and substantial connections make people feel 'this person is alright, they're one of us'